Why is it that we who believe in God take…

Why is it that we who believe in God take issue with atheists and others who claim that everything just came into existence by mere chance, randomnesses, and chaos; and adamantly argue against them by saying that there is a Creator, a Prime Mover (Unmoved Mover); but yet when it comes to the subject of choice, we’re willing to believe that choice arises from a void, a place of mere chance, randomness, and chaos?

Does choice arise from a void? A vacuum devoid of cause and effect? Something from nothing?