Author
What can you say about this: Atheist claim that the…

What can you say about this:
Atheist claim that the Bible has contradictions?

Discussion

158 comments

  1. Nigel Riley says:

    Ask them which contradictions and why these “contradictions” matter.

  2. Jeff Rey says:

    thank you for the answers guys!

  3. Argentino PowtotheChow Escuyos says:

    Tell them they are full of contradictions in their philosophical thinking.

  4. Jeff Rey says:

    there example of contradiction are found in

    Gen 32 when Jacob wrestles with God and named the place “face of God

    contradicts it in John 1:18
    no one has ever seen God

  5. Daniel Chiasson says:

    This is simply an false opinion. If they would truly do the research they would see that their claims are baloney.

  6. Jeff Santiago says:

    Let them show us those contradictions

  7. Karl Ernst Von Buddenbrock says:

    THey’re predisposed to say that. They don’t respect revelation (and its obvious superiority to their rationalism) so they disrespect it. They’re not willing to examine the so called contradictions

  8. Colleen Moore says:

    Some things in the Bible can be conflicting to the human spirit, but it’s the Holy spirit within a person that opens their heart to see the truth in God’s word.

  9. Spencer Williams says:

    There are only apparent contradictions to surface skimmers of God’s word

  10. Dwayne Sanders says:

    Why would atheists make any comments about any religion and it’s contradictions. They’re all fairy-tales anyway? Right?

  11. Mike Cresswell says:

    Answer, “thanks for telling me, I’ve been reading it for 30 years, where are they? Can you point them out, I cant find any!”

  12. Glen Earl Person says:

    My first question would be is “Give me an example”

  13. Grace Williams says:

    Why do us has to prove that there is no contradiction in the Bible, though? It’s up to them to prove there is no God.

  14. Marcel Van de L'Isle says:

    It looks like, but if you read the Bible without guidance of the Holy Spirit it will not only be full of contradiction but also strange

  15. Darren Clark says:

    Atheist books have contradictions and incoherent statements, but that does not imply that the atheists don’t exist, or that you can’t trust those atheists on other things that they say.

  16. Ed Atkinson says:

    Yes, contradictions do matter. Eg if there are contradiction in the gospels then we have to treat them as unreliable testimony. Even the authors themselves understood that principle. See this in Mark 14…

    55 The chief priests and the whole Sanhedrin were looking for evidence against Jesus so that they could put him to death, but they did not find any. 56 Many testified falsely against him, but their statements did not agree.
    57 Then some stood up and gave this false testimony against him: 58 “We heard him say, ‘I will destroy this temple made with human hands and in three days will build another, not made with hands.’” 59 Yet even then their testimony did not agree.

  17. Lober Bornales says:

    To those who are blind spiritually think bible has contradictions. Challenge them to read it with an open mind not with bias

  18. Nigel Riley says:

    Unreliable testimony is not the only verdict open to us. For starters we need to decide whether the disputed section is foundational or not. Additionally, are we looking at a scribe’s copying error? Or accurate reporting of a genuine confusion? Scripture was recorded by fallible people, surely capable of occasional mistakes – all of which increases, rather than detracting from, the Bible’s authenticity.

  19. Girishlal Tamta says:

    Ask the Atheist how he found contradiction whether by truth test like reliability,validity,unity, compatibility, universality and plousability.

  20. Mark Jones says:

    I hear this all the time, how I approach it is I ask the atheist to cite one example and explain why they feel it is a contradiction. I’d always try to keep this subject as a discussion. I often find that a lot of sceptics (particularly online ones) haven’t actually read up on these and have picked them up from YouTube videos, blogs, memes, etc. However, you will find people who have thought them through.

    I’d also add, that if they use the scattergun approach, ask them to select one to discuss. If they won’t do that, then you select one for them. If you find they don’t want to engage then it’s OK to dust off your feet and move on, you’ve tried to discuss a contradiction with them and they don’t want to discuss it, so they’re reasons for discussions are probably not genuine if they do not engage.

  21. Emmanuel Montoro says:

    Description
    DescriptionIn classical logic, a contradiction consists of a logical incompatibility or incongruity between two or more propositions. It occurs when the propositions, taken together, yield two conclusions which form the logical, usually opposite inversions of each other. Wikipedia

    contradiction noun
    To save this word, you’ll need to log in.

    Log In
    con·​tra·​dic·​tion | ˌkän-trə-ˈdik-shən How to pronounce contradiction (audio)
    Definition of contradiction
    1: act or an instance of contradicting
    the defendant’s contradiction of the plaintiff’s accusations
    2a: a proposition, statement, or phrase that asserts or implies both the truth and falsity of something
    … both parts of a contradiction cannot possibly be true …
    — Thomas Hobbes
    b: a statement or phrase whose parts contradict each other
    a round square is a contradiction in terms
    3a: logical incongruity
    b: a situation in which inherent factors, actions, or propositions are inconsistent or contrary to one another.

    Yet they fall to present a clear and undisputed evidence to their claim, the same as for evolution, the goodness of humanity with out GOD, etc,etc.

  22. Wesley Dover says:

    You usually have to take the “contradictions” case by case. The Big Book of Bible Difficulties would be a good resource.

  23. Ronald Mckinney says:

    Sad

  24. Philip Davis says:

    from an secular and un-revealed perspective it always will but the theme, from Genesis to Revelation is coherent…that they cannot deny.

  25. Jim Grosso says:

    Pray tell what contradiction? The Bible has been dragged under a microscope for 2k years. No one has found one yet.

  26. Harry Jones says:

    There are not contradictions in the Bible!!!

  27. Gus Rodriguez says:

    Misinterpreted by them, doesn’t mean contradictions. Most of them just repeat what they hear from their atheist friends or teachers but they don’t bother investing their time checking it out.

  28. Stephen McCulloch says:

    There are many contradictions in the Bible. It is entertaining to watch the hermeneutical gymnastics of those who deny them.

  29. Kenny Laatz says:

    There are many points in the Bible to hang your doubts on…..do this at your own peril.

  30. Steven Chakarovski says:

    It can look like that but when you study the context and interpret correctly it looks different. Understanding biblical theology helps.

  31. Tom Osborne says:

    Yeah well they also say that there’s no God. ?

  32. Travis Lipscomb says:

    The Bible itself has zero contradictions. The view points of eye witnesses will always be different. Based on time of account, what they saw, what points were important. If everyone’s account was identical this would be clearly a made up recited story. Not a personal account.

  33. Stephen Howsare says:

    No it doesn’t.

  34. Mark Frost says:

    Nope none. There is a book called something like proving over 4000 contradictions or something like that it goes through everyone they ever mention.

  35. Richard Rosas says:

    Yeah, it contradicts atheism

  36. Emanuel Mullen says:

    Look at where your source of information is coming from “an atheist!” Can you believe anything they say? Absolutely Not!

  37. Josh Payne says:

    Typically the atheist doesn’t care to have each contradiction explained because they just give another and another. I have it better to just ask, if there are contradictions does that mean Jesus was not raised from the dead.

  38. Joe A Smith says:

    Atheists claim many things

  39. Glenn Buchanan says:

    You clearly don’t know the author.. He is flawless

  40. Ingþór Örn Valdimarsson says:

    I know. They say alot of things. Like the universe exploded out of nothing. That is another contradiction.

  41. Jim Grosso says:

    Atheists are a gullible bunch.

  42. Les Kloot says:

    I agree with Mark Jones. Ask for just 1 example. You can’t deal with being flooded by 1000 contradictions they trawl off the internet. Deal with them one at a time. Feel free to inbox me for help. I get most of my answers from the bible commentaries.

  43. Matthew Ellis says:

    Typically this is based on either an ignorant view or willful ignorance about scripture. If you start asking for specific examples, you’ll usually find that they have a very limited view of scripture.

  44. Brad Hopkins says:

    When an atheist says that, ask them to point one out. They cannot because they just parrot what they hear other people saying.

  45. Danny Warren says:

    Show me one.

  46. Madison Willoughby says:

    I’d say they are too lazy to do the hard work of studying the scriptures to find the truth. Those words are nothing but a coward’s easy out.

  47. Jonathan Gianacoplis says:

    If you want to see contradictions you will find them. If you trust the Holy Spirit to guide you then they will not be contradictions. Many people have pointed out contradictions to me over the years (especially Liberal Christians). At first I would get nervous with what they told me. Then after reading the Bible for myself none of them ever seemed to really be contradictions at all.

  48. Jonathan Gianacoplis says:

    Another question that I often ask is why did the early followers put these books together if they had so many contradictions. We have Iraneus a follower of John who basically had the NT put together as it is today. If you were choosing a book to support your religion would you put one together with so many contradictions??? Those who lived closer to the time of Jesus were either too dumb to see the contradictions and we are soooo much smarter 2000 years later or they did not see these contradictions as contradictions. ??‍♂️??‍♂️??‍♂️

  49. Robert Jarvis says:

    I’ve yet to meet an atheist who actually knows the Bible well enough to say that- they are just parroting something some one else has said

  50. Jon Poe Atkinson says:

    How can the Bible contradict itself, if an atheist doesn’t believe it?

  51. Hans Krug says:

    You just have to explain each apparent contradiction they may cite one by one. And I have never seen one that doesn’t have an explanation and is not a contradiction as all.

  52. Jereme McAlpin says:

    There are no contradictions when taken in context

  53. Ken Leeder says:

    Just ask them to elaborate they are the ones making a false claim it is on them to prove their hypothesis

  54. Cody Ashton Hitchen says:

    The bible has no major theological or doctrinal contradictions.

  55. Mark Marley says:

    Ask them which one bothers them the most…

  56. Sally Barron says:

    I would say, show me. Most “contradictions” are simply verses taken out of context. Even Christians are guilty of this, you can make almost any individual verse say what you want it to. Numbered chapters and verses were never in the original documents, they were all added. It would be like writing someone a ten page letter, than having a total stranger pick out one sentence, and try to use that to describe the entire letter. It can’t be done. Every book in the Bible has to be taken as a whole, not a just a group of random sentences. When read that way, they don’t contradict, they amplify each other. The other types of “contradictions” are Paul said this, but James said that. Those you need some Biblical knowledge to explain who they were talking to, and what was going on in that particular congregation at that particular time

  57. Joseph Ace says:

    The bible has variances over 5,000 of them but none of them affect any of the doctrines.

  58. Maribel B. Krause says:

    But if thine eye be evil, thy whole body shall
    be full of darkness. If therefore the light that is in
    thee be darkness, how great is that darkness! Matthew 6.23

  59. Gerry Sebastian says:

    Matthew 7:6 (NASB): Do not give what is holy to dogs, and do not throw your pearls before swine, or they will trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you to pieces.

  60. Lunden Aries says:

    They dont understand the distinction between contradictions and paradoxes

  61. Andrew John Laatz says:

    Atheists will swallow their words and then their tongues and then they will swallow themselves…, and then POOF!!! they will be gone!

  62. Jeff Brady says:

    Of course there are. Heck, there are two different creation narratives in the couple chapters of the whole book.
    It’s a collection of 66 books with many different authors.

    Put 35 of us in a room, ask us to prayerfully answer one question about God – how many answers do you think we’ll get when each of us prayed and asked God to give us the answer?
    God inspired the authors but there are issues of context, language, history not to mention eons of time distance between us and their initial words. Of course there are contradictions!

    But the question is, is our faith big enough to see through these things that the God of the Universe is over all, in all, and through all? Can we trust that the cohesive story of God throughout Scripture is more powerful than contradictions?

    Why do we fear? The faith is strong, and our God is stronger.

  63. Anthony R. Vacanti says:

    Apparent “contradictions” are routinely resolved with a more thorough familiarity with the Word of God. The doctrines and events and quotations of Scripture do not present themselves as if they were part of a Divine File Cabinet. Other critical ingredients are found in other Gospel Accounts, in other epistles, and often even in the other Testament! To fully understand any single idea, every other contributing facet of that idea must be included. To not do so gives rise to the false accusations of “contradiction!”

  64. Richard Mascioli says:

    Most “contradictions” can be resolved by reading them in context and doing a little background research. Many discrepancies are due to variations in translation. There are no true contradictions.

  65. Fred Galvez says:

    All of scripture is true. One passage complements and adds to the other. We must accept this and incorporate all of scriptures truths into are correct understanding. The scripture itself states that it does not contain everything. Scripture further refers to the church as the pillar and Foundation of Truth 1 Timothy 3:15 . We must remember that for the first 350 years after Christ death is there was no scripture ? Only many and a growing number of loose manuscripts which needed to be compiled .. but what church was given the authority to do that? It is good to read the early history of the church has written down by those first practitioners of the way who lived between the year 100 and 350. They are known as the early church fathers and their accounts are genuine.

  66. Chris Lindsay says:

    “What does that have to do with atheism?”

  67. Pv Joseph says:

    Atheistic claims of biblical contradicts lie in their inconsistent premises of logical assumptions!

  68. George Albinus says:

    Alleged contradictions in the bible don’t exist. There are not two creation accounts just two different angles. One disciple remembers two angels at the tomb, another remembers one. They didn’t visit the tomb at the same time so their both right. No man has seen God completely in his glorified form or you’d be incinerated, human for of course-there’s 88 appearances of God in a tolerable human form in the OT. Moses saw the backside of God and developed a radiant face that people couldn’t directly look at. Close encounters of the God Kind should be a bible documentary.

  69. Victor Van Der Woude says:

    The Bible is a large book and takes a lifetime to study and comprehend. Proper hermeneutics skills and honest interpretations within this framework is possible. But nobody ever become an expert on everything to do with scripture- to large a task

    What Atheists sometimes do is play instant experts and misinterpreted what they quoted in scripture. Set up straw man arguments using Old Testament laws against modern standards without consideration of context.

    These contradictions are more atheists misunderstanding of scripture than substantive proof of what they are really claiming (it’s a human document only and unreliable).

  70. Jabbar Musayev says:

    There are many contradictions in the Bible

  71. Wayne Johnson says:

    I have yet to see an atheistic objection to Christianity that hasn’t been thoroughly answered by countless theologians.

  72. Brian A Dimond says:

    Ask them to show you where hut you will need to be able to accurately give proper context. These conversations usually are like I use to be, ask then questions they can’t answer adequately and then bash them for not knowing. Choose your battles and know the what, where, why, who, enough for the battles we walk into. It is not like everyone one of us knows all the answers to every question. We are all students.

  73. Darrell Hendricks says:

    The bible was written by human beings who were inspired by God. Their personalities and interpretive understandings remained their own yet within the context of God’s Sovereignty . As such it is understandable that there would be perceived contradictions in the bible which when looked at in its larger context is in fact no contradictions at all.

  74. Nick Pavlick says:

    Another stupid post…sigh

  75. Kelly Johnson says:

    Ask for specifics

  76. Jack Johnston says:

    Kelly Johnson: Well, internal questions with the Bible are usually answered with hundreds of words as to why the Bible does not mean what it means because when the Bible does not make sense, apologists are bound and determined to give it another sense.

    But, let’s consider passages from the Bible that contradict external standards with verifiable reality.

    (1). The Bible states there is a solid-domed firmament in the sky over a flat earth keeping back the heavenly waters from flooding the earth.

    (2). The Bible names four rivers that have a single source, but geography shows those rivers do not have a single source.

    (3). The Bible says Pi is 3.0, not 3.14.

    (4). The Bible says stars can fall from the sky.

    (5). The Bible says genetics can be determined by magic sticks.

  77. Cl Ing says:

    That is a Hypocritical Contradiction.

  78. Joseph Baumbaugh says:

    I don’t believe in Atheists

  79. Jack Johnston says:

    Kelly Johnson: Let’s consider some internal problems you have probably never considered before.

    The O.T. says that the Aaronic priesthood is everlasting; yet, the N.T. says it is done away and has been supplanted by that of Melchizedek.

    The O.T. says that nothing shall be added or taken away from the law of Moses; yet, a large portion of the New Testament is all about telling us why the law was not good enough and needed to be changed with the New Covenant and all that goes with it.

  80. Daniel Otache says:

    never believe in atheist

  81. Jack Johnston says:

    Additionally, the Bible can’t get math right. In Matthew, we learn that there were three sets of fourteen generations in Jesus’ genealogy which should add up to 42 generations. However, there are only 41 names with one set only having thirteen names.

    Overall, there are at least ten other problems with math in the Old Testament not forgetting the geometry problem with Pi from 1 Kings 7:23 above.

  82. Daniel Otache says:

    dont forget he is the begining and the ending, author of no confusion, bear as you see.

  83. Ellis Gray says:

    I always wondered why people don’t believe in God but use His name in vain all the time.

  84. Alexander Price says:

    It has many contradictions in it. It also has all Religions in it from Kemet Islam Buddhist Wicca the Bible has everything in it. So with that being said, all faiths Religious text have contradictions in them.

  85. Jabbar Musayev says:

    The Jewish Bible never teaches the virgin birth. Matthew insists that Isaiah wrote about Jesus’ birth from virgin Mary.

  86. Gary Stapp says:

    The bible says to rightly divide the word of truth. You can make the bible say anything. You have to rightly divide the word of truth and also be a Christian to understand any of it. 1 Corinthians 2:9-10

  87. Adam Daniel Broughton says:

    The Bible has seeming contradictions. If it contradicted itself it would be incoherent. So you could start with that, and put yourself in the position to allow them to challenge it. Then work out the seeming contradictions. If you are unable yourself to work it out, the issue has likely been addressed by others and you can refer to their solutions. After working a few out, if they keep bringing up more, it’s likely that they simply want the Bible to contradict itself. That doesn’t mean it does.

  88. Jehu James Bautista says:

    Most of you, just lack of the study. There are no contradictions only misinterpretations and out of context. Too long to answer from comments.? Search the answers for yourself if you really seek the truth.

  89. Collin Mack Barham says:

    I’d say show me and we would talk about each one they bring up. There are no contradictions just misinterpretations.

  90. Erasto Resty D. Policarpio says:

    EVEN THEIST TWIST GODLY DOCTRINE IN THE BIBLE, CREATE & IMPOSE THEIRS, KILL DOCTRINE/WORDS OF GOD, WHT CAN U EXPECT FROM ATHIEST…

  91. Fred Galvez says:

    Hay y’all happy Memorial Day ! Lets have some hamburgers ! I’m outa here ?

  92. Tomas Toledo Herrera says:

    The Bible it not cotradict itself at all , whath happens is that they can not understand it because only the Holy Ghost can explain it to you when you accept the sacrifice of the Cruz.

  93. Carlos Sotelo says:

    The only thing the Bible contradicts is their unbelief but their unbelief validates the Bible.

  94. Kris Lagrelle says:

    Most contradictions I have “found” are mostly due to either lack of distinction between literal and figurative, as well as lack of understanding in the root language and translation!
    Once past that paired with the Holy Spirit! It’s smooth sailing and all makes sense!!
    No contradictions ?

  95. Temitope Bolarinwa says:

    Athiest are living in dilusion. Do you know Satanism is the foundation of Athiests?

  96. Temitope Bolarinwa says:

    You see the Cross makes no meaning to those that are perishing.

  97. Doreen Heintschel says:

    The letter of the word kills, but the Spirit of the word brings life.

  98. Rondel D. Methvin says:

    To the Atheist: “What led you to believe the countless contradictions that exist within the myth known as Darwinian Evolution?”

  99. Victoria Grea says:

    Atheism contradicts itself for it says that God does not exist, but in saying God does not exist you are acknowledging that there is a God. For there has to be something in order to say that it is not….

  100. James T. Mickles says:

    The Atheist whole entire life is a contradiction

  101. Wamulunji Wabukhonyi says:

    Usually, I ask the person to show me one contradiction. From that point, I can help him or her see the Bible for what it is; not what he/she has been told

  102. Gabriel Roberts says:

    We have to understand what the bible is and what the word of God is. I’m going to take one of the most commonly known biblical contradictions as an example. The four gospels have differing account of how many women or angels there were at the tomb of Jesus. They all say different things about the number. In truth, the number doesn’t matter. What we’re supposed to know is that there were people and angels there, even more so that Jesus was resurrected at all. The Bible is just a book, it is no more than pages and text, but the word of God is the message that we get from reading the text. The text will almost never be 100% perfect, but the message is. The same goes for its scientific and historical inaccuracies. The numbers in the bible, when added up, account to about 6000 years. Sadly, because of this, many Christians believe that the world is only 6000 years old. What most don’t know are that the numbers are meant to be symbolic rather than literal. This is a very foreign concept to western culture, but think exaggerating, saying 1,000,000 years to represent a long time. The bible is not supposed to teach science, nor 100% accurate history down to the number, but instead lessons of theology, the commandments of God and the Gospel – the word of God. Yes, there are contradictions, but the Bible is inspired. Not every little word is from God, but its messages are inspired by him. We’re not to believe that the Earth is flat or that the world is 6000 years old, but we are to believe that Jesus Christ is our lord and savior and that he died for our sins. All scripture is God breathed, but so is humanity, and we aren’t perfect either.

  103. Jim Koverman says:

    Name one!

  104. Nick Shara says:

    Don’t waste your time with them. In my experience they invest 12 seconds in their argument. They went to google and looked up “errors in the bible”. Then they copied and pasted someone else’s list which THEY DIDN’T VERIFY, and sent that list to you, and they want you to invest several hours of your time to dissect it.

    I tell them. “Take the process you used to find those errors, and use the exact same process to find solutions for yourself. Go online and google “solutions to errors in the Bible”.”

    End of story.

    If they won’t even bother to invest their own time in finding answers, then you shouldn’t invest your time either.

  105. Jeremy Brown says:

    Nope…the Bible has no contradictions.

    That said, don’t waste time or your spiritual energies defending the Bible against a mocker, scoffer, or reviler.

    They will never be satisfied with enough proofs are evidences, and they simply move the goalposts, their only goal is to mock, revile, and attempt to wear you down… It is literally a waste of time to engage in that particular activity with that particular type of people.

    I’m not saying don’t share the gospel with them. I’m saying give them the word, and let the Holy Spirit either draw them to God or harden their heart through it.

  106. Kevin Julien says:

    Not contradictions but misunderstandings due to scripture being taken out of context or misunderstood due to not properly investigating the actual traditions or meanings as understood from that day. Just as spoken words of today could be misunderstood by people from 2000 years ago due to lack of understanding of our traditions, slang, and meanings of the day. This is why study is in order. Oh, one other thing, the Holy Spirit needs to be present as well. If He is not present, you will lack the fuel necessary to: MOVE THAT BUS! (Extreme Makeover)

  107. Zane Lawrence says:

    Its an atheist scam

  108. Ben Peckover says:

    That’s an attempt at using logic. Which is human reasoning. Which has no foundation outside of a Christian worldview. God cannot lie because he is truth. If we think we see a contradiction, it’s because there is an aspect or detail that we haven’t understood. The problem is never with God’s word, it’s with us.

  109. Pradeep Roy says:

    Atheists claim a lot of things about Christianity which are simply untrue, e.g. the Bible condones slavery. They really don’t know anything about the Word so it’s best to take their claims with a pinch of salt or better still ignore them completely. If the mood strikes you, give them a bible and ask them to point out a single contradiction and rebut their argument.

  110. Jason Billingsley says:

    Show me where is what I would say. 99% of the time an individual who says this is just repeating what others have said and can’t really show you any contradictions.

  111. Carl Bedford says:

    Look deeper

  112. Joshua Stoley says:

    A claim without evidence and warrant is nothing more than an unsubstantiated opinion…

  113. Joe Faulkner says:

    Bible says atheists are full of contradictions…

  114. Eric Ngala Mutumbi says:

    There are no contradictions in the Bible at all!.Tell me where you do not understand that I may explain to you.For example if one writer says as they were leaving Jerusalem and another say as they were entering Jerusalem, it doesn’t imply contradiction but what is important to know here is where the writer or the eye witness was standing at that particular time!

  115. Stephanie Lynn Oaks says:

    Atheist also claim there is no God!

  116. Langzakham Sonna says:

    One who contradicts God sees contradiction in the Bible too.

  117. Morena Mashile says:

    The bible has about 400k textual variations not contradictions. They may confuse these two components.

  118. Romeo de Dios says:

    So they are no longer atheist, so let us reach out to them, we have to mention them in our prayers,,,they are lost they need Jesus through us….let us be compassionate…

  119. David Jaywant says:

    They simply never understand. Let them go to Paris and jump from Eiffel tower. Straight away they can meet their prophet Charles Darwin and wait for the judgement day.

  120. Peter Hunt says:

    Cool. Let’s discuss. Which ones?

  121. Todd Salapa says:

    I guess it depends on what contradictions specifically. It has been my experience that once someone digs deeper in the scriptures although a passage may be difficult to understand there is often an answer to the contradiction. When I have had questions about a contradiction in the Bible, I research it to find a genuine answer.

  122. Scott Shifferd says:

    We should not reinterpret the Bible to reject it and think we’re honest.

  123. Rohn Timm says:

    True.

  124. Tim Jones says:

    People roll that one off there tongues as standard issue for reject God and the Bible! Always out of context with no concept or understanding of Biblical exegesis and cultural ways of writing!Always superficial in their statements.

  125. Greg Coupe says:

    How does one tell if something is a real contradiction or if it is not a real contradiction?

  126. John Carson says:

    I usually ask, “How many times have you studied the whole Bible?” Most will say they have read some of it, to which I let them know if they kept reading and studying, they would discover their accusations are unfounded.

  127. Jack Parks says:

    Atheists have either not looked at the “contradictions” themself, have not sought answers for them, or have outright rejected explanations. Atheists aren’t well known for their hermeneutics. And this shouldn’t be a surprise. The things of the spirit are foolish to the unbeliever. The natural man cannot understand.

  128. Jeff Adolphson says:

    I’d ask them to prove it.

  129. Ryan Johnson says:

    1. Jesus was born in Bethlehem/Jesus was born in Nazarus

    2. How many fighting men were found in Judah?

    Five hundred thousand (2 Samuel 24:9)
    Four hundred and seventh thousand (Chronicles 21:5)

    3. How did Judas die?

    4. How old was Jehoiachim when he became king and how long did he rule over Jareusalum for?

    5. How did Simon Peter find out that Jesus was the Christ?

    By a revelation from heaven (Matthew 16:17)
    His brother Andrew told him (John 1:41)

    6.Who was the father of Joseph, husband of Mary?

    Jacob (Matthew 1:16)
    Hell (Luke 3:23)

    7. Jesus descended from which son of David?

    Solomon (Matthew 1:6)
    Nathan(Luke3:31)

    8. Did Jesus bear his own cross?

    Yes (John 19:17)
    No (Matthew 27:31-32)

    9. What did Jesus say at his trial?

    10. Did the jews condemn Jesus at his trial?

    11. Did Jesus speak at his trial?

    I can keep going a hell of a lot more. Innacuracies and contradictions are everywhere in the Bible.

    There is nothing wrong with this and it is to be expected for a book written by dozens of authors across multiple centuries.

    The problem comes when the believers think it is infallible.

  130. Taylor Drake says:

    I would suggest further study, reading the passages in their historical and literary context, recognizing cultural influences and author intent. Most times the “contradictions” are easily dismissed and addressed. It’s not an argument; it’s studying.

  131. Mark Fonner says:

    Atheism is a contradiction in and of itself.

  132. Isaac Julian Rivera says:

    Contradictions exist for the fools like them. The Bible says, ” the fools say there is no God”.

  133. Herbert Bradford Jr says:

    The Bible is for believers. It is impossible for an atheist to understand.

  134. Kim Kay says:

    I would say show me where?

  135. Nicholas Garrett says:

    I love this one. The Bible has footnotes when a verse has translation issues, or when wording did not appear in the original text but did in later translations. If you’re trying to trick somebody with lies and contradictions seems rather silly to put foot notes in the book. Usually the contradiction accusation comes regarding the gospels and the old testament books that give inventories with differing information. In every other subject under the sun it is understood that eyewitness testimony will vary from person to person. I would not even grant that there are contradictions in a debate. I would stage a 30 second event and then ask five different people from the audience to describe it. Done right there.

  136. Briso Bell says:

    The bible has contradiction to only those who don’t read and meditate daily.
    God makes understanding to those who trust in Him, Those who seek Him day and night find Him. If any one treasures his word to find gold and silver He is not Hidden

  137. William Clark says:

    I think that at face value, they’re right, but only in appearances. Without context of traditions, history, customs, laws of the land at THAT time, etc, the bible DOES appear to have contradictions. The bible can be cherry picked to the point of making God look like a madman to the point that Hitler and Stalin would look like angels. The bible can ALSO be cherry picked to the point of talking about God’s love with absolutely no mention of His wrath. Both sides doing this are a disservice to God who is the God of love AND wrath.

  138. William Clark says:

    I’ve downloaded PDF documents free online that actually PROVE that the bible DOES contradict itself IF the reader refuses to take into account…..history, laws of the land, customs, etc. Once you bring a thorough understanding of ALL of this together, I BELIEVE that any discrepancies actually go away. I might not like what I read about what I personally believe a loving God should do, but my belief that God may be wrong in something (because I can’t possibly comprehend that kind of purity and righteousness) does NOT negate any research that I’ve done so far showing that the bible does NOT actually contradict itself at all. My research is NOT exhaustive, but it’s pretty comprehensive.

  139. Sheila Anne says:

    The best source you can show him/her is the Bible. God did not give us all the answers. Some things are a mystery known to God. Once this person heart is open to God, He/she will receive Jesus as their Savior and the Holy Spirit will teach them.

  140. Jeff Adolphson says:

    Posting some simple errors is not the same as a contradiction.

  141. Dennis Mitton says:

    I say, “Christian’s make the same observation. So what?”

  142. Karl Ernst Von Buddenbrock says:

    The atheist is trying to hide. Don’t even entertain his argument. (S)he will get you chasing your tail. We don’t owe them an explanation for so-called “contradictions”. They must listen to God’s word, or exercise their free will and go their own way.

  143. Rick Stone says:

    They have always said this , straining at things they do not understand, oddly undermining the only book that can give a certain hope of redemption, leaving them with the yawning chasm of hopelessness

  144. Myvanis Lombard says:

    It often seems like their are contradictions, but there are none. Each one has a part elsewhere that explains it or support it.
    In some cases there were copyist errors, that make no difference to the message at all.

  145. Art Ellingsen says:

    I have been asking Atheists to show me a Contradiction for over 50 years and I have not seen one yet. That is a real Contradiction, not something they assume is a Contradiction, which isn’t. Everything in the Bible is correct. Whenever in history, it appeared that the Bible did not agree with the Bible, eventually, Science caught up with the Bible, not the other way around.

  146. Chester Higgs says:

    even the devil is a believer, motive and objective is now the question? we are asked not to argue and cause strife

  147. John Calogrides says:

    Ever notice the so-called “athiests” (yeah, right) get downright angry with people who really insists on their belief in a sovereign God….but they wouldn’t get mad at people who believe in unicorns, Santa Claus, or leprechauns. You can’t get mad something you know is not real. And for people who believe in them silly things, you would just dismiss them as fools and not waste 5 seconds of your life debating with them. Because you know they don’t exists. BUT…. So called “athiests” (yeah, right) go to fill 6 lengths and full anger against God belief. And as I’ve said before, talk to them long enough, as I have, and you WILL find they DO believe God exists, they just don’t like it…..

  148. Steve Sears II says:

    Ask them to be more specific. Likelihood they cannot be so, and then there is no need to argue further as they are mearly spouting off the standard atheist talking points. If they give a specific supposed contradiction give an apologia for the supposed contradiction. If you cannot, gracefully ask that they give you time to look into that and provide them with an answer at a later date and time.

  149. Steve Sears II says:

    I would encourage you further to read a book called Tactics by Gregory Koukl.

  150. Donald Peacock says:

    Aeithist don’t understand the bible. There are no contradictions.

  151. Donald Peacock says:

    On this post we have Christians and atheist going back and forth. Both the walk of the Christian and the atheist is a walk of faith! As Christians are we showing non believers in this case atheist the love of Christ or are we just attacking them. Is the atheist On my on here to mock the Christian? This should be a forum of seeking answers not finger pointing as to who is right and wrong. Lets ask and answer questions with the spirit of love! I would like to do a zoom on this topic.

  152. Michael Howell says:

    If you read the bible and find contradictions, you are reading it wrong.

  153. Dianne Beers says:

    Quote one contradiction

  154. Den Collins says:

    A fool also says in his heart there is no God.

    I won’t be counseled by fools.

  155. Michael Hurtado says:

    Whenever someone points to a contradiction it usually turns out not to be the case

  156. Donald Peacock says:

    You believe the bible is the infallible word of GOD or you don’t!! It is that simple!!!

  157. […] What can you say about this: Atheist claim that the… […]