Author

From my readings in all of the various different Christian groups, and those more specialised towards apologetics, there seems to be a great deal of people who have difficulty with devine election, or devine predestination. I can sympathise with this.

If Calvinism is true, then all peoples, both good and evil, are predestined towards a certain path which they will walk. If this is to be believed, then God is the auther of evil, and thus not good (meaning that he is not the source of love and good, meaning that He ultimately cannot be God)

But, if open theology is true, then God is impotent, being unaware of future events. If God is impotent, then he cannot be the source of all knowledge and power, meaning that He is ultimately not God.

But there is a third way, a middle way so to speak. God not only knows past, present, and future events, but also the past, present and future events of that which never happened, but could of happened if things were different (for example, would I buy a lamb if I were rich?). God knows not only what you WILL eat for breakfast tomorrow, but also what you COULD eat for breakfast tomorrow, and how such an action would ultimately change the future of everything.

This is a doctrine known as molinism, and it pretty much solves the issues with divine predestination in the bible. God has total control of the outcome of all events, but you ultimately make the choice.

A biblical example of this can be found in first Samuel chapter 23;

“But David learned of Saul’s plan and told Abiathar the priest to bring the ephod and ask the Lord what he should do. 10 Then David prayed, “O Lord, God of Israel, I have heard that Saul is planning to come and destroy Keilah because I am here. 11 Will the leaders of Keilah betray me to him?[d] And will Saul actually come as I have heard? O Lord, God of Israel, please tell me.”

And the Lord said, “He will come.”

12 Again David asked, “Will the leaders of Keilah betray me and my men to Saul?”

And the Lord replied, “Yes, they will betray you.”

David Hides in the Wilderness
13 So David and his men—about 600 of them now—left Keilah and began roaming the countryside.”

I’m aware that some of you may already be aware of this doctrine, but this was written for those whom it would profit.

God bless

Discussion

8 comments

  1. Chris Lindsay says:

    Molinism and middle knowledge are such rich theological concepts. They have applications to so many areas of theology, and they resolve the free will/divine Providence problem pretty well.

  2. James A. Henson says:

    That’s middle knowledge…don’t think so.

  3. Jenny Marie says:

    I don’t believe God made people specifically for hell I believe he created us all equally but we ultimately walked out our lives in free will and made the choice. Since he is omniscient he knew in advance what choice they would make but did not create them to make that choice or make it for them

  4. Rizaldy S. Menor says:

    So thst is molinism… Thanks.

  5. Robert David Van Meter says:

    Open theism is ridiculous. Also, this is a theological question, not apologetics

  6. Jenny Marie says:

    Christian Apologetics Christian Apologetics you denied my post I tried to put up about Calvinism saying we hAve to respect other people’s beliefs because we are all in this together but you allow this post up which is discussing the Calvinism doctrine (that of course is false which is fine) however my point is how is it fair he can make statements about Calvinism being a wrong teaching but I can’t make comments about Calvinism being a wrong teaching

  7. Jerrod Hall says:

    If God looks down the corridors of time and chooses based on our decision (what molinism teaches)that means God had to learn something and make a choice based on that knowledge.i really don’t believe that’s what the Bible teaches about God,i love talking about this subject though and recognize that more often than not,our rejection of a certain doctrine is usually based on an incomplete or incorrect understanding of that doctrine.that goes for me as well in the case of molinism,which as of now,i don’t believe

  8. […] From my readings in all of the various different Christian… […]