Author

Cause and Responsibility

In judgement is the outcome and result the only thing that matters and not causes?

We hear a lot about Adam’s sin, but not much about what caused it.

The presence and impact of the Serpent in the Garden of Eden is a factor in Adam’s fall that must be taken into account. Where did the Serpent come from? How did the Serpent become evil?

Just as Adam had a factor that led to his fall (the Serpent), what factor led to the Serpent’s fall?

Cause and responsibility must be determined to achieve righteous judgement. We don’t blame the victim for a crime caused by a factor beyond the victim’s control.

If a woman is raped do we hold her accountable, or the cause and factor that led to the crime?

We do have a thing in our law books called not guilty by reason of insanity or mental defect. We recognize that there are factors that can influence and determine behavior, and we render not guilty verdicts based on the overpowering nature of those factors.

In the final analysis which of us is really in a position to have all power over the factors that determine who we are and what we do? Did we create ourselves and the reality we live in?

No. We are created and living in a reality that we had nothing to do with. No one chose to be born. No one chose the reality that is our existence.

Discussion

8 comments

  1. Larry Koester says:

    God’s justice and ours is not tbe same. He knows us better than we know ourselves in side and out. But we can only see what is outside of a person and that imperfectly.

  2. Sarah Wellet says:

    The serpent was possessed by satan. He convinced Eve (and adam) to eat of the forbidden fruit, he did not force it in their mouth. They were the ones who sinned. Just like if someone convinces you to steal something, you are not the victim of theft but the perpetrator.

  3. Ryan Wangen says:

    Can’t have freewill without having a choice between 2 or more options. Can’t have genuine love WITHOUT freewill else humanity would be robots. Evil doesn’t exist on its own but is the privation of good. Just like we can have light without shadows but can’t have shadows without light.

  4. Yehoshua Marion says:

    Furthermore if you take away our free will you take our ability to learn to become more tomorrow than what we are today I don’t really want that taken away I value that.

  5. Duane L Burgess says:

    The “forbidden fruit” was not an apple!

  6. Duane L Burgess says:

    “Free will” is a poor term. It’s inadequate and inaccurate to represent what Scripture teaches.

    God is not “free” to sin so what does “free” actually mean?

    We were created as self directed individuals, or, free moral agents.
    Our mind is free to choose, but our will is enslaved to sin.

    The root of the controversy over “free will” is actually rooted in Genesis 3, where mankind is tempted to be in control.

    “Free will” is, in it’s essence, the cry of prideful rebellion, “I am in control of my destiny.”

    To declare “free will” is not acknowledging human responsibility; it makes man sovereign in salvation, not God.

    Man’s free will lead to the Flood of Noah. Man’s free will supresses the Truth in unrighteousness. Man’s free will crucified Christ. Man’s free will shakes a fist in unrepentance amid the tremendous calamities of the Great Tribulation.

    As Jesus declared, No one CAN come to the Father unless He draws them.

  7. Simon Kiriba says:

    Adam was not a victim. He chose to sin. A victim is the person raped not the rapist. If you stretch your argument to its logical conclusion, a person who rapes children is a victim and should not be held responsible.

    The entire justice system is premised on presence of choice and responsibility.

  8. […] Cause and Responsibility In judgement is the outcome and result… […]