Author

Going off my previous “What happens to the souls of babies”, it’s also important to consider the question:

“What about those who’ve never heard of Christ?”

Now, I know Romans 1 says that we are without excuse because of creation, but I don’t see how that makes people know specifically about the Christian God. Most cultures the world see creation and believe in their own God (Thor, Zeus, etc.), but believing in a false god will not save them. I think it comes down to a few options:

1. Predestination: God simply didn’t elect them or predestined them to be saved, so they will go to hell. This may be the simplest solution, but obviously one that calls into question God’s love.it also doesn’t explain why God created them in the first place, as it seems that not existing would be better than burning in hell.

2. Middle Knowledge: God knows what people would do, so anyone who would want to be saved is saved in the actual world. This assumes that everyone who isn’t saved, including those who don’t hear, would never freely accept God in the first place. But that again raises the question as to why God would simply not create those who He knows would reject Him.

3. Annihilationism: Those who don’t hear simply cease to exist, rather than burning in hell.

4. Universalism: People may go to hell temporarily, but all will eventually repent and go to heaven

5. “Escapism”: The unreached are saved in the same manner as OT saints; they may go to hell originally but eventually escape. However, unlike universalism, not everyone will choose to freely accept God while in hell.

Which of the options is the most likely to be accurate? I think all of these have problems, but some are better than others.

Discussion

29 comments

  1. Alan White says:

    Maybe none of the above

  2. Richard Andrews says:

    I highly recommend the book by Don Richardson, Eternity In Their Hearts! Extremely informative on answering your questions in this. God’s blessings to you! https://goo.gl/search/Eternity+in+their+hearts
    Eternity in their hearts, Book by Don Richardson

  3. Luap Iyasi says:

    What is the rational of using the African Zulu people celebrating their culture in this thread? Does it suggest that the Africans in the picture are not Christian?

  4. Bob Bosch says:

    Shouldn’t this sort of thing be clear?

  5. Shane Johnson says:

    God does not send innocent people to hell … But the truth of the matter is that no one is innocent … All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God

  6. Ricardo Perez says:

    Perhaps it would be enlightening to hear additional ideas on what God may have planned to answers those questions. They are a burden to many Christians. Might it be possible that the answers are in the Scriptures but we have not fully grasped it yet. Any additional opinion? Thanks for the question.

  7. Nadine Walls Bailey Mossner says:

    I heard a well-known apologetics minister answer the question at a college about reconciling the doctrine of free will and predestination. I loved his answer. He said he believes it means that God knows who will accept the gospel if they hear it and he make sure they do. Are you aware that even now he has appeared to people in the Mideast where it’s very difficult to get the gospel in personally and they have been saved? That is not hearsay. That is been verified by Ravi Zakaria and others. He is so merciful and kind and desires all would be saved. However, mini just do not want him and there’s nothing we can do about it except pray for them. That’s the hardest part of being a Christian I think. Knowing that

  8. Isaac Olufemi Adekunle says:

    You are without excuse!
    God will never use what you normally don’t know to assess your eternity merit

    That standard of behaviour that you ever known and regarded as the best way of life for a ‘perfect’ human being shall be used to judge you!
    The ONLY problem is, outside Jesus Christ’s Atonement, the Grace is non-existent. Law/tradition, norm, punishes so ‘the wages of sin is death’ will be applied, and this is why Jesus came to die for mankind since laws (anywhere) is holding mankind to eternal ransom. Therefore, THE GIFT OF GOD IS ETERNAL LIFE THROUGH OUR LORD JESUS.
    That’s Saving Grace!

  9. Eric Licayan says:

    Go to them and preach the gospel ,that Jesus is Lord and believe in their hearts that he is rose from the dead. then he shall be save Rom .10:9-10

  10. Eric Licayan says:

    You must study rightly dividing the word of truth. 2Tim.2:15

  11. Okewole Emmanuel says:

    1. How do you know such an individual died without hearing about Christ? This is purely an assumption. Until this is proved that someone died when he hadn’t heard the gospel, one cannot initiate the debate on God’s position on his matter.
    2. Concerning the infant who died, it depends on the his age or level of assimilation on the platform of knowing what is right and wrong. Better still, it will be necessary to read passages of the Bible the talk about King David’s response, reaction, attitude, and choise of words shortly after the death of his infant child born to him by Beersheba.

  12. Okewole Emmanuel says:

    On the five items listed above, NONE OF THEM IS LOGICALLY PHILOSOPHICALLY, OR THEOLOGICALLY CORRECT.
    They’re all defective through the lense of the Bible both in the OT or NT.
    Shalom

  13. Aaron Vgp says:

    I think we are all judged on our knowledge of God. If we have heard the gospel and reject it then we are judged on that.
    For people who never heard the gospel they are judged on their knowledge of God. Is that through their various tribal religions? Who knows!

  14. Lukas Dohnal says:

    To your first question I answer. The only Christian God claims to be one yet three and that is exactly what we see in all we see. The trinity is a mystery of Gods ability of being as unity in diversity, Ravi Zacharias said.. I believe just for three years and until few weeks ago I had no understanding of trinity whatsoever, I believe it “only by faith” I don’t claim I understand the trinity now but I can at least comprehend the “sense of it” thanks to probably most unlikely Bible verse I would ever imagine being as revelation in this issue Romans 1/19,20. Paul say that what is known about God He has revealed it in His work, The creation in the context of these two verses. So what is known about God. He is ONE !! One God, the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit.. wow I said one God but I named three persons, that’s the mystery isn’t it. In Colossians 2/9 we read that in Jesus the fullness of Deity dwells bodily. FULNES it says. In Romans 1/19,20 we read all we have to know about God He revealing in creation. So God is ONE full in trinity of Father, Son and the Holy Spirit, unity in diversity. Creation= ONE universe full in trinity of time space matter. Cannot have just space and matter without time because when would you put that matter in the space. All three are meaningless without being trinity. Time=ONE time full in trinity of past present future, again impossible to separate them. Space= ONE space full in trinity of high depth length (3D). Matter=ONE Matter full in trinity of solid liquid gas, and it goes on even atoms are like that. ONE atom full in trinity of electrons protons and neutrons. I can see Gods unique imprint in all He created. I mean He claims to Be One full in trinity thousands of years before we understand this physical basics about our universe. I am not comparing our God to some simple stuff, but for me it was a revelation How can God claim to be One yet three.

  15. Caleb Backholm says:

    3 is a likely answer, but “in hell”, not “rather than hell.”

    Also they are responsible to respond to what God has revealed to them thru nature and their conscience. Some may be saved this way, but probably very few. Hence the need for missions.

  16. Marisa Johnston says:

    I always thought of predestination not as God choosing some and not others, but rather already knowing who would and who would not choose him, if given the chance.

  17. Tony Duncan says:

    Revelation 20:14
    “ Hell and Death are thrown into the lake of fire …which is the second death”

    1 Corinthians 15:53
    “ for this mortal must put on immortality”

    Genesis 3:24(paraphrased)
    “ so God drove them out of Eden and put a flaming sword to guard the tree of life
    So man could not eat from it and live forever”

    Revelation14:11
    “And the smoke of their torment ascends forever “

    #1 man is mortal
    #2 hell and death are destroyed
    #3 the “ smoke” is a vapor a mere memory not the person himself

    #4 a man must be born again Spiritually
    Because men are born spiritually dead

    1 Corinthians 15:22
    “ in Adam all men die( Spiritually)
    But in Christ all me can live( Spiritually)

    #5 Christians live forever because they are born again

    “This mortal must put on immortality and this corrupted must put incorruptible “

  18. Jay Gypsy Bryant says:

    I don’t have the answers, although I can’t help but think that a perfect God wouldn’t have a perfect plan whatever that may be.

  19. Salvador Retchie Grant says:

    None of the above listed options are accurate. What is accurate is what Paul said that even those apart from the law MAY be justified.

    Romans 2:13-16

    13 (For not the hearers of the law are just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified.

    14 For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves:

    15 Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another;)

    16 In the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ according to my gospel.

  20. Calvin Yehezkiel Limuel says:

    Number 3 is just a description of Annihilationism. Destruction of the soul will happen whether or not you’ve heard about Christ. And it would still be compatible with Number 1 (namely John Stott) and Number 2.

  21. Calvin Yehezkiel Limuel says:

    I’m neither subscribe to Hell as eternal conscious torment or annihilation, but that it is a realm that’s opposite to peace and order in heaven, rather chaos and anarchy. Also, I’m a Molinist so soteriologically I lean on 2 more than 1. But there is slight correction I want to make.

    We are indeed saved by good works. Not by believing in a correct god. Wait that doesn’t sound biblical? It really does. But not our good works, rather the good works of Christ, because our works are tainted. And when we say that we believe, we believe that Christ’s good works replace all our bad deeds so God sees our righteousness rather than our sinfulness. So if anyone is condemned to hell, it isn’t because they do not believe in a correct god, but because they have all sinned, and corruption cannot enter heaven.

    And the second correction pertaining to the points, all Christians should believe in predestination, no matter if you’re a Calvinist or Arminian or Molinist or Open Theist. But Middle Knowledge is almost exclusively a Molinistic thought, if not also Open Theistic to some extent. And there are many interpretations based on God’s predestination and God’s foreknowledge, your points are merely one examples each.

    For example, I don’t really agree to what you put in for Middle Knowledge. I really don’t think about it that way, but only that in God’s middle knowledge, that God actuated the best possible world, where without compromising any of God’s standards, that the most number of people would be saved.

  22. Charles Baldini says:

    God will reach His elect no matter who or where they are!!!

  23. John Edgar Erasmus says:

    Maybe God will judge those in His supreme judgement according to a standard which will be fair to those that have not heard of Christ.

  24. DA Siebert says:

    ?following?

  25. Λευτέρης Πανηγύρης says:

    I wont try to give a biblical answer , ill ask you something a bit different. Are you a Christian? If you are , you believe in a God who is perfectly Just and Merciful.
    Do you trust an all loving perfectly Just and Merciful God to do the right thing ? I would trust that God.

  26. Dana Salomon says:

    Hell is real. People who do not want God, get to be apart from Him who is love. This leaves them time of hate or indifference.

    But we must remember that both death and hell are cast into the Lake of Fire, this makes us consider that death is not necessarily the same thing as hell, but it is not blessed with eternal life.

    Revelation 20:14

  27. John Eksted says:

    Why are you questioning God? He is the creator and judge. He is infinite in wisdom and knowledge. His nature defines Love goodness Justice and righteousness.
    You may find fault with my theology but not with God.
    The answer is as always “Trust Him to always do what’s right.”

  28. […] Going off my previous “What happens to the souls of… […]