Enoch walk with God yet his book was removed from the Bible why??
Discussion
50 comments
-
Enoch was a walker not a writer. hehe
-
Because it wasn’t written by Enoch. It wasn’t written until about the third century BC and Enoch lived about 2200 BC
-
Right the message in the book of Enoch was just handed down verbally from the time of Noah till they actually wrote it on manuscripts. However this doesn’t necessarily denounce the book as of no value. It’s just not a book to be used as an inspired context like the books of the Bible. More along the lines of a study aid or reference book. I believe a lot of what’s in the book of Enoch helps fill in gaps that the Bible doesn’t cover.
-
Because it contains inaccuracies and contradictions.
-
Ask the holy spirit.
-
He did not write.
It was uninspired as of our 66 books -
It’s not his book.
-
The book of Enoch claims that’s after God took Him up, he came back.
Genesis says God took up Enoch “and he was no more”. The book of Enoch contradicts the truth of scripture.
Also, the book was clearly not written by Enoch… The dates don’t line up anyway. -
I’ve listened to extracts from this “Book of Enoch” which concentrate on the Angelic fall. I really want understand more.
-
who “said” there was a book ????
-
The Book of Enoch has five parts:
1. The Book of Watchers, composed in the third century BCE.
2. The Book of Similitudes, composed in the first century CE.
3. The Astronomical Book, composed in the third century BCE.
4. The Book of Dream Visions, composed during the Maccabaean revolt, 165-160 BCE.
5. The Epistle of Enoch, composed in the early second century BCE.Since Enoch lives around 2200 BCE, and the Book of Enoch was written over a period of 400 years, beginning in the third century BCE, it clearly was not written by Enoch, who lived 365 years on earth.
But there’s no answer to your question. You ask why the Book of Enoch was removed from the Bible, but the fact is, it wasn’t removed. It was never included in the first place, so it isn’t possible for it to be removed. So I can’t tell you why it was removed, because it wasn’t. But if you want to know why it isn’t included, just read the above.
-
Because his name spelled backwards sounded too much like a swear word in the original language and it has been said that once it is seen it cannot be unseen.
-
Not a great answrr here but think about it…just another book to add to the list of books most christians don’t study. I do believe God has given us what we need…anything more would just deter us from studying His Word
-
Not inspired!
-
Did he write a book?
-
It prophesied the coming of the books of the Bible but was not to be a part of it. It is mentioned several times in the Bible. It is a very good book. It goes into more detail than a lot of the Bible accounts.
-
Deut 29 ;29 thats all for now.
If enoch book was writen ,would it make us love the lord more ?? Would it help me to deny self more ? I think God has revealed what needs to be revealed the rest we shal ask When we get to heaven -
I walk with god and I have no book
-
Enoch was never part of the Bible and isn’t divinely inspired. It was a novel written during the silent period from God from Malachi to John the Baptist.
-
The Book of Enoch is thought to have been written sometime between 94-64 BCE which is far removed from the historical time that Enoch lived. The Book of Enoch was definitely not written by Enoch and is considered to be pseudepigrapha, a forgery. You can read the Book of Enoch for fun or to learn about the culture and thought of Jews during the intertestamental period.
-
Too much evidence that the book was not written by Enoch.
-
The scholars decided to remove it when Noah spoke to lamauel his late grand father asking him about the scary dream that was about the flood which will end the world.. So they decided not to put it on the bible because they thought it will encourage necromacy( talking to the dead) and ancestral worship
-
No it was not removed from the Bible it was never in it to begin with, and it was not included because it is not inspired of God, it is not the only book not included and for the same reasons.
-
1. The authorship cannot be established and is believed to be falsely attributed to Enoch.
2. It was never truly considered scripture by the early church.
3. The book of Enoch is never referred to as scripture by Jesus nor any new Testament writer.
-
Because it was not quoted by Jesus or the apostles, which every other OT book is. That was one of the standards used to determine cannon.
Also Enoch was antediluvian(pre-flood), the antediluvian world was completely destroyed except for Noah and the Ark.
Anything attributed to Enoch cannot be verified -
He walked too slow
-
I’ve always wondered that myself
-
It is there and very rich …
-
It’s Quoted in the Bible
Hence
It’s trueWhy wasn’t it acceptable?
Very simply
Lilith
The Jews who said what is acceptable and not could not accept the truth that Adam had a first wife
Jews believed this for years
Even hence why the Bible says that the Christians burned their magic books, this is because they practiced something like kabulla today and it involved magic pendants that protects from LilithThe idea that demons are real
And that a woman rejected Gods word and created all these beasts from mating with fallen angels.Just makes the story screwed up eh?
It’s true and “convincing” doesn’t need to happen.
Most witches get their power from Lilith and her beasts (personal experience)But it looks bad
God creates man and woman
Woman won’t submit
So she has sex with demons
Second woman he made out of man
So she has to submit
She is too gullible that she listens to the devil to screw it all upWhy wasn’t Adam “punished”
Eve was told to submit to her husband (the only commands given to woman until the Ten Commandments, guess blow jobs weren’t illegal until Baptist’s, ha)Eve was punished that she can’t preach
And she will have birth painsAdam??
Boldly took the fruit
Knowledge and good and evil
He deliberately defied godBut only punishment was he had to work???
Oh he’s gotta sweat ?But she is his servant and has physical pain?
It’s because one woman already rejected Adam
And the second was too dumb to not follow instructionsSo now Adam has soul bonded with two women
He had no option to eat of the fruit ?.
She was deceived
Not him -
Everyone that walks with God and authors a book don’t get published in the Bible. Why is that?
-
With our 3 pounds brain, we can not comprehend ‘plausible’ principles like this, especially if it’s only a conjecture.
-
because his book wasnt part of the Bible to begin with.
-
why are people obsessed with the book of Enoch.
-
it was not removed,it was never accepted as part of the bible.
-
Go and look at when Enoch died and when his book first surfaced. Look at the year difference between the two events and ask yourself why. Also, examine the historical background of today’s “Book of Enoch” and investigate for yourself why Hebrew old testament rabbis never accepted it as canonical.
-
Because he didn’t write it?
-
It was never his book. It openly contradicts Genesis. If the book of Enoch is true, then Genesis cannot be.
-
We are not worthy of it?
-
My name is Isaiah, and I write stuff. Why isn’t it included in the Bible with the rest of the book of Isaiah?
-
I recall Enoch stating an Angel was moderating for humans which only Jesus can do.
-
Well in Genesis Enoch himself just disappeared, so obviously his book would do the same thing. Enoch’s book is “walking with God: and is no more [part of the canon]; for God took it” 😉
-
Book was not inspired!
-
The NT book of Jude, it mentions Enoch.
-
The book of Enoch has nothing to do with Salvation.
-
Because the book contents are not from him to stand a valid testimony, though it holds some values on reflecting the ancient Jewish concepts.
-
Who wrote the book of Enoch? We are certain that Enoch existed and God took him, but the book of enoch is not inspired by the Holy Spirit. Remember God is perfect, He perfectly preserves His Word so we can know it.
-
It was never part of the Bible. The two or three ‘books of Enoch’ were all fakes proved to be so.
-
So did Stephen and many other godly men.. but they did’t have a books either.. talk more of adding them to scriptures.. the Holy Spirit inspires we ought to be glad we even have some to read.. who is man to say what gets in or not.. especially given its proven to not be God-breathed
Comments