Author

In Muhammad’s claim that he’s a “clear messenger” he doesn’t deliver a very clear message..
He appears to say that even by the standards of the Revelations Allah gave him for salvation, he’s unsure of his own salvation..

Muslims say this is because “he’s a man and not a deity” Even as a man, if he believed his Revelations were true shouldn’t he be confident of his salvation if he were walking in these statutes?
Paul was confident of his salvation by the Revelations given him from the Holy Spirit..

If Muhammad isn’t sure of his own salvation, why did he write a book about what Muslims must do to have salvation?

There’s a catch 22 that comes with this scripture..
He’s either one of two things..
1.) He’s a liar, and charlatan which made up the Revelations rendering him truly clueless of his state with God’s true standard of salvation.

This is evidenced by the question of, is there a more perfect Muslim than Muhammad? Obviously not… So if he’s unsure of his own salvation by his “Revelations” what Muslim could be sure of theirs by the same standard of the Quran written from the supposed “prophet” unsure of his salvation by the very Revelations he wrote in it? Or-

2.) he’s a heretic of his own religion, and a fraud which chooses to rebel against the Revelations Allah gives him.
If he believes his Revelations are true, and he’s walking in the statutes of them, he should be confident of his salvation right? The only plausible explanation of his “un confidence” if it’s not option one, is that he’s an infidel who doesn’t obey Allah’s Revelations.

Discussion

21 comments

  1. Lukas Dohnal says:

    If you ask Muslims “how do you know you go to heaven” ? They answer (always) “your good deeds must outweigh your bad deeds” so they have no certainty. It does not make any sense though. It’s same as anyone would stand before judge and judge would say “ok you are guilty but you done some good things also you are free to go” why don’t I ever seen it on earth ?? If there was a victim in court room He would probably alarm the newspaper saying “there is a judge far more wicked then the suspect, He is corrupted” I am debating Muslims sometimes, and I found that in Islam there is no logic !! Logic is law actually, for instance, I know there is a second Heaven even though Bible does not mention it anywhere. But Bible clearly mentions third heaven and since there is a third heaven there must me also second one because there has never been anything third unless there was a second one also. But in Islam it’s forbidden this way of thinking it’s also (as I hear from Muslims) forbidden to mixes science with religion. Muslims say “science is not religion” there is a reason for that and it’s because some things in Islam simply don’t make sense. I ask Muslims how Allah demonstrated his love towards them, telling them how Living God demonstrate his love towards me (cross, living relationships, everyday fellowship) and they don’t know how to understand my question even. Their god is “carved in stone” Never talking to them, except in a book given by one prophet. It’s dead religion no living relationship with God just rituals. It’s heartbreaking to me, literally. I am praying for Muslims every day Hoping God will rescue them.

  2. John Watson says:

    Because Mo was a fraud.

  3. Shane Johnson says:

    He was a murderous paedophile … False prophet and one of the little horns in Revelation .. an antichrist

  4. Jerry Spencer says:

    Mark 15:34
    At three o’clock Jesus cried out with a loud voice, “Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?” which means, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”

  5. Jerry Spencer says:

    And at the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, “Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?” which means, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”

  6. Tony Xavier says:

    Death to the infidels

  7. Libna T Biju says:

    But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.
    Revelation 21:8 KJV
    https://bible.com/bible/1/rev.21.8.KJV

  8. Trey Rodriguez says:

    I I’m not a clear Warner.”

    Also Quran.

    “Allahs word is perfectly clear.”

  9. Wendy Beard says:

    Because Satan appeared to Mohammed claiming to be Gabriel. Even Mohammed believed it was really Satan. However, instead of praying to God for deliverance, he succumbed to Satan and wrote the Quran, killed many people, and had multiple wives including little girls: rapist and pedophile. It is appalling that anyone would want to name their child Mohammed or that anyone reveres this man. Satan has deceived so many with this false religion.

  10. Martha Coffa says:

    LOL ?

  11. Toni Armstrong says:

    That’s what you get from a false prophet

  12. Anthony Hollis says:

    John 14:6.?

  13. Elijah Ayuago says:

    He is Satans messenger

  14. Jazmine Miller says:

    Following (I would answer myself, but I’ve never read the Quran, just the Bible and I know my view is based on my own bias therefore it’s irrelevant).

  15. Obed Newmai says:

    Now in the gospel, Jesus has risen from the dead and the immediate witnesses were those Roman soldiers who guarded the Jesus tomb, so how do we argue with those Jewish people at present that to believe in this factual Resurrection story? Those guards were paid in huge ransom amount as written in order not to tell the truth to the people and so they lied and till today that covered story turned into a true story and yet not true.

  16. Alex Dunn says:

    Why are their postings of a piece of trash on this page?

  17. Dan Farnow says:

    Interesting point. Nabeel Quereshi, a former devout Muslim, wrote about this (I love this guy). Him and a devout Christian studied the evidence to support Christianity and Islam. For instance, they reviewed and scrutinized the three tenets of Christianity (1. Jesus died on the cross, 2. Jesus resurrected, and 3. Jesus was God) and the two tenets of Islam (1. the Quran is the inspired word of God/Allah and 2. Muhammad was His chosen prophet)… When Quereshi and his friend read sources about Muhammad that were considered the most reliable, they saw some behaviors not consistent with the way a prophet would act (i.e. endorsing soldiers to rape women of a conquered people group). Also, there was, early on, a recall of all the Qurans, so some problematic writings could be revised, which was not consistent with it being the inspired word of God (or Allah)… However, with Christ, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were all written within 40 years of Christ’s death and were circulated among the very people (including those who had Jesus killed) who would have refuted it if it was not accurate. Instead, we see people profess Him as Lord when they knew they could be killed for saying that.

  18. Andrew Coiner says:

    I think Muhammad knows jesus is the Christ. You constantly see him back tracking on his own words. It as if he knows he is deceiving people.

  19. David Payne says:

    I feel like people arent seeing the message. If the belief is we cant fathom God’s plans or actions then why should a mere man suggest such. He lives his life in the hope he receives salvation yet doesnt know how he will be judged. To the person in question, how well does Muhammed know the person. He may know what the man shows him yet the man may have darkness in his heart for which Alah may judge him harshly. If the counter is Christians get into Heaven so long as they believe in god, what would be keeping a Christian from doing evil things nobody knows about? God could judge him harshly while his friends assume he’ll get into Heaven upon his passing.