Which is the perfect picture of Salvation? 1. We were…

Which is the perfect picture of Salvation?
1. We were in a point of drowing deep into the water gasping for air until we saw Jesus hand and we reached out to Him and He pulled us out and we are saved.
2. We were drowning and we totally lose our breath and we at one point we were dead and sinking deep into the water and then Jesus dive in and pull us out of the water and did a CPR on us and we were alive and saved.