Author

There’s a lot of controversy surrounding the story of Jonah and it’s validity. From people saying the throat of a whale isn’t large enough to swallow a man, to the objection of the idea a man can survive in the belly of a fish for 3 days and 3 nights…

To begin, the Bible uses the word “fish”, though a sperm whale is capable of swallowing a human whole, There are also fish capable of swallowing humans whole as well, one being a “whale shark”.

Let’s hypothetically say one of these sea creatures swallowed Jonah, how could Jonah Survive? I personally believe without miraculous disruption of physics by God, Jonah wouldn’t have. I believe Jonah’s life was preserved by God, now why would God do this to Jonah?

To punish him… Many people which grew up watching Christian kid shows like Veggie tells have this misconception Jonah was sitting in the whales Belly like it was an empty room.
I believe Jonah was suffering. I believe the stomach acid of the whale was eating his skin, and the fluids within the creatures belly suffocated him to where he couldn’t breath. I believe he was in an immense, unfathomable amount of pain for three days and three nights, so much he wished he’d die but couldn’t..
Why? Perhaps because God was giving him a small taste of the eternal punishment the Ninevites would receive if they didn’t repent so he’d be more appreciative of his duty.

There’s layers to the possibilities of why God would use this event as a means of teaching Jonah a harsh lesson and preserving his life simultaneously. Nonetheless: the objection to the story of Jonah is founded on narrow minded, pre conceived conclusions which object the miraculous power of God out of dogmatic ignorance. I believe the story of Jonah is 100% logical under the premise of an all powerful God capable of defying physics.

Discussion

15 comments

  1. Larry Koester says:

    Why look for a natural fish? We are dealing with God here, not a silly human. The silly human was Jonah thinking he could avoid doing what God wanted. The other miracle was Nineveh repenting, then there is the withering of the vine.

  2. Adam Monty says:

    Even the Jews see this story as allegory.

    It is the meaning of the story that counts. Not whether it actually happened.

    https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/jonah/

  3. Ed Weems says:

    With God all things are possible, he can even make the sun stand still in the sky, he can call a trillion Locust down on your head oh, he can part the Red Sea and he can hang the moon in the sky I’m sure putting a man in a whale is not a problem for my father. He designed your DNA and you doubt that he can put a man in a whale stomach gamma how are you going to believe that he can raise the Dead? If my father speaks it it is done.

  4. Seth Iris says:

    This is impossible while Daniel in lion’s den is possible. Daniel’s friends in the fiery furnace is possible.

  5. Daz Gordon says:

    It always seems strange to me why people strive to prove the possibility of the amazing events in scripture by presenting an arguments based on what is possible naturally, at the end of the day day supernatural powers where exerted by a supernatural being ie God , so trying to prove that the amazing events that are spoken about in scripture being possible by what occurs naturally is in a way a denial of the true God glorifying way and means by which these events came to pass .

  6. Joshua Jenkins says:

    We believe in a God, who created the world from nothing, and you believe he couldn’t create a specially designed fish for Jonah?

  7. Wayne Johnson says:

    It all goes back to the greatest miracle. That of the creation of the universe. If God can speak and create the Universe into existence then all of the events of the Bible are possible for Him.

  8. Jason Norcross says:

    We believe God created this world/universe and raised His Son on the 3rd day, but somehow we can’t believe that a large fish could swallow a human, then toss him out? The almighty God who controls weather, calms the seas. The possibility is very real when you consider all the other things God has proven to have done.

  9. Tom Joseph says:

    I wonder if there are any skeptics who have a problem with Jona and the whale but not with God reconstructing us from ash and worm poop?

  10. David McCroskey says:

    I like to remind people that the Bible wasn’t written in English. Good post btw

  11. Jay Zeke Malakai says:

    There is an alternative interpretation popular in Jewish circles that Jonah actually died, and prayed from the grave, before being resurrected.

  12. Bill Carleton says:

    No question it happened.no problem .it’s what God chose.i believe .we are talking about our creator who does miracles .

  13. Bob Jones says:

    It doesn’t have to be logical it is God

  14. Mark Jones says:

    With the Jonah account I think there are two issues with people’s responses that are common:

    1) Fish Don’t Do That … Therefore it Didn’t Happen

    This is an assumption based on a lack of data. Several things have to be taken into account with this account. Firstly the Bible depicts the events of Jonah happening around the reign of King Jeroboam II which is almost 3,000 years ago now. With the time difference between then and now, you have to consider the possibility that even if there isn’t a type of fish that someone could survive in for 3 days and 3 nights now that there may have been then.

    There is also the aspect of assuming that this couldn’t happen today. Oftentimes people assume that things that DON’T happen CAN’T happen. That is a leap … it is entirely possible that someone in this day and age could be swallowed by a large fish and surviving, we just don’t have any confirmed records of it happening in recent times.

    2) It’s Impossible, Therefore It Didn’t Happen

    This links very much with the problems of the first objection. We don’t know that this is impossible, many just assume that it is because there isn’t any recent examples of this happening.

    But let’s just say that it was impossible. Things are only impossible within the natural realm as things can only be possible if they do not violate the laws of nature. This however, would not be the case for God who is a supernatural being and would therefore be able to operate outside of the laws of nature and would be able to interact between both the natural and supernatural realm. We see this in the Bible with the many miracles that God has done. So with that in mind, could Jonah’s survival simply not just be a miracle? It is entirely within God’s wheelhouse to make that happen.

  15. […] There’s a lot of controversy surrounding the story of Jonah… […]