Author

I was reading about open theism. The belief that God has limited, if any, knowledge of the future. That the future is open, and not set.

I don’t agree with open theism. The future is full of possibilities, but those possibilities will only result in one outcome.

“We may regard the present state of the universe as the effect of its past and the cause of its future. An intellect which at a certain moment would know all forces that set nature in motion, and all positions of all items of which nature is composed, if this intellect were also vast enough to submit these data to analysis, it would embrace in a single formula the movements of the greatest bodies of the universe and those of the tiniest atom; for such an intellect nothing would be uncertain and the future just like the past would be present before its eyes.”
– Pierre Simon Laplace, A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities

9 Remember the things I have done in the past.
For I alone am God!
I am God, and there is none like me.
10 Only I can tell you the future
before it even happens.
Everything I plan will come to pass,
for I do whatever I wish.
– Isaiah 46:9-10 New Living Translation (NLT)

Discussion

13 comments

  1. Mong Santiago says:

    The frustrating part about Open Theism is its hermeneutics which seems to be unnatural. You can present proof texts that God has foreknowledge of the future but their strange hermeneutics does all that it could to to drive that away from the Scripture

  2. Dan Jasper Ordenes Verdera says:

    The prophecy for niniveh is conditional…

  3. Duane L Burgess says:

    Open theism is heresy.

    There can be challenging events and issues to study in Scripture. But in time we can clarify, discern and harmonize the interpretation.

  4. Pst David Njoya says:

    It couldn’t if they repent.Jonah preached as such.

  5. George William Tyler says:

    Now we have some understanding of cosmology we see the possibility of something other than the universe, outside of space-time, and see God saying, “I Am”, Jesus, before Abraham, “I AM”. He is outside of time, no past or future. He “is”.

  6. Joel Lee says:

    Imagine having perfect knowledge of everything to ever happen. Imagine knowing how to change events, knowing exactly all outcomes and results. Imagine a limited being you created questioning your knowledge.

  7. Jesus Balmaceda says:

    Have you ever seen a replay of a game? Like a Super bowl or something? You know the outcome of the game, you know what team is going to win and what player is going to do what in the game because it’s a replay, that doesn’t mean the players of the team didn’t have free will just because you now know how the game is going to end, that is the same way God knows the future, quit trying to fit the Almighty in your human brain and it’s not to be misconstrued that life is a replay

  8. Todd Carpentier says:

    Clearly God lives outside of time. To him, every single sliver of every single moment has already occurred. He sees the end and the beginning simultaneously. So while we live on a sliver of time, and are free to make our own choices – he’s already seen the choices we make.

  9. Alan Parsons says:

    The idea of God’s knowledge being limited contradicts the idea that He is all knowing.

  10. Skarlet Pike says:

    If He had not told them, they would not have repented and He would not have relented from the calamity coming to them.

  11. Adam Daniel Broughton says:

    Shortest sermon ever. It’s almost like Jonah didn’t want them to repent or something…

  12. Victor Van Der Woude says:

    Open theism must shut down G-d’s attributes in a way that makes H-m meaningless for Christians as an active deity in History. It also seems to prefer humanities finding G-d without H-s intervention. It maybe more difficult to understand how predestination and freewill interacts but open theism isn’t the answer.

  13. […] I was reading about open theism. The belief that God… […]